Nature blogging: a lot of discussion time was spent on what exactly a “nature blog” was, with a clear division between those who viewed nature blogging as a broad church, with the more science-oriented blogs as a subset of various other approaches, and those who view nature blogging as distinct and separate from science blogging. I thought it rather odd that so many of the latter camp were at a science bloggers’ conference; isn’t our whole underlying purpose that science is something everyone can (and does) do, not just the weird freaks in the lab coats? If you’re going out and looking at stuff, that is science. I may post more fully on this later, but I think I bored enough people with my ranting on the day, so maybe not.
On the other hand, it was a good point that sometimes “show” is a more inclusive approach than “show and tell” – or at least, “show and lots of tell”…
Hey, you can’t say that: This was progressing into an interesting discussion about the need to consider the consequences of posting our thoughts on the internet for all to see, and the degree of responsibility we bear for those consequences, but it stalled somewhat on some rather utopian aspirations for employers to unconditionally stand up for their staff’s right to free speech, and unionisation.
The real take home message – one I certainly took on board – was that employers don’t like surprises; and if you haven’t discussed your blogging with them beforehand, and the first time they find out about it is when an irate donor or shareholder calls them onto the carpet, you shouldn’t be surprised if they might be a little upset. Proactivity is to your advantage, although it seems that you have to watch out that the agreed ground rules don’t shift under your feet, as happened to one of the panellists, or that the press office start trying to muscle in for their own gain.
One thought that I’ve been wrestling with through this and yesterday’s ‘Transitions’ session is that my blog is inextricably entangled with my day job. Thus, my personal blogging can’t help but be entangled with my professional persona, and I therefore do have responsibilities to my employers. This blurry line is certainly not just my problem – and blogging is still such a new thing that exactly what those responsibilities are have yet to be properly thrashed out. James and Karen were both vocal – and, I feel, entirely correct – in advocating that we should take the lead on this, rather than continuing to let the next controversy shape the debate.
Science blogging networks – what works, what does not? A rather meandering closing session, to be honest, which could be characterised by lots of rather defensive talking past each other – it was about 3/4 of the way in before someone rather sensibly pointed out that Scienceblogs and Nature Networks were two entirely different beasts, with different aims, and different strengths and weaknesses. Plus, I remain astonished about how exercised everyone gets about our private forums – given the number of times people complain about the lack of science on scienceblogs, you’d think people would be glad that we at least kept some of the noise off the front page.
Search this blog
- Environmental Earth Science in the News Roundup #6
- L’Aquila earthquake manslaughter verdict reversed
- Water Infrastructure and Rebounding Cities: Notes from the 2nd Annual Kent State Water Symposium
- Tuesday dispatches from GSA: Vancouver
- Monday dispatches from GSA: Vancouver
- Sunday dispatches from GSA: Vancouver
- Environmental Earth Science in the News Roundup #5
- Environmental Earth Science in the News Roundup #4
- On Environmental Earth Science News Roundup #2:Mountaintop removal mining: what it looks like and what it does to Appalachian streams:The Napa Valley quake, and why California is (geologically) not part of America at all.:
- Lockwood: For the first Accretionary Wedge I hosted, My post was more or less focused on the lack of... Read
- Chris Rowan: Grrr. I keep on getting that wrong… thanks for the quick heads up! Read
- Kim: The fault tips curve toward each other! It’s so gorgeously textbook! (Also, east of the San Andreas.... Read
- Steve Watson: On our last visit to the UK, my cousin took us out for a ramble above Hathersage. There were lots... Read